Fort Myers, FL Real Estate Search

Fort Myers, FL Historical Homes for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for historical homes available in Fort Myers, FL and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Fort Myers, FL real estate market? Sign up for a  Fort Myers, FL Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Fort Myers, FL Historical Homes for Sale

$295,000
2 Beds 1 Baths 224041892 MLS Edison Park BLDG.
Are you a Hometown Hero, a First Time Home Buyer or a Retiree? This is your opportunity to own a cute 2 bedroom + den/family room and 1 bath home with in Historic Edison Park. Financial grant or assistance availabe to qualified buyers, ask your Realtor or lender for details... Walk to Edison Elementary & Fort Myers High schools, Lee Memorial Hospital, Edison Ford Estate & Garden! Free pickleball, tennis and basketball courts around the corner, along with soccer and baseball field... Ride bike to Downtown River District, Theaters and Musemus within 5-10 minutes. This home is in a great location for smart living!!! Home is ready, move in condition with newer paint, tile floors, new roof, new windows and a cozy kitchen with all appliances. 1-year AHS Warranty in included for your peace of mind. Also included are washer & dryer. Fireplace has not been used for few years and sold "AS IS". Lovely back patio deck to enjoy your morning coffee or evening drink! Storage shed provides a place for your garden tools. Enjoy gardening - plant butterfly and bird garden or herbs garden if you like cooking! If interested, furniture is available out of real estate closing... Sandy beaches are 30-45 minutes, Twins and Red Sox Spring traning stadiums are 20-30 minutes, and I-75 and RSW International airport is 30-40 minutes... Enjoy good life and subtropical climate in Fort Myers! Enjoy photo and virtual tour, then call Realtor to preview and get it! PS:Home on east side is an office for Thrift Stores and no one lives there or stores items. This home is zones Professional Office - adding value!

2455 Cortez Blvd, Fort Myers

$405,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 224041211 MLS Dean Park BLDG.
Nestled in the heart of Dean Park, Fort Myers’ only neighborhood on the National Register of Historic Places, this charming 1920's Craftsman Bungalow offers a perfect blend of history and community. Originally owned by former mayor Vernon Widerquist, this property is ideally situated at the pinnacle of the neighborhood, directly across from the delightful Triangle Park and at the corner of Rhode Island Ave and Providence St. While brimming with potential, this unique home awaits restoration to return to its full glory, requiring a new kitchen, electrical upgrades, and plaster wall repairs. It features a wealth of original details, including original heart pine hardwood floors, built-in cabinets, and original glass windows that flood the space with natural light. The residence is complemented by a spacious 360 sq ft guesthouse, boasting four rooms with brand-new amenities, including a kitchen, bathroom, and efficient mini-split air conditioners. The property includes a detached garage/workshop and benefits from recent significant upgrades: a new metal roof installed in 2021 with a 50-year lifespan, New ducting added in 2022, and New Foundation supports (helical piles) in 2023. Outdoors, the front and side yards hosts vibrant young mango trees, and the fenced backyard features a majestic 100-year-old oak tree, making it an ideal retreat for relaxation or entertaining. Living in Dean Park, you’ll enjoy a tight-knit community with regular social events, beautifully palm-lined sidewalks, and an atmosphere of belonging. This home represents a rare opportunity to own a piece of Fort Myers’ history in a location that is truly the best in the neighborhood. Sellers have a TRANSFERABLE FLOOD POLICY! Agents, please see remarks.

2673 Rhode Island Ave, Fort Myers

$1,350,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 224041044 MLS Valencia Terrace BLDG.
Old Fort Myers - Stunning 1926 Spanish Style tucked away on a sought after street on the Riverside of Historic McGregor Blvd. This thoughtfully updated home has all the features for modern day living while keeping its vintage charm fully intact. Features include original hardwood floors, a spacious floor plan with high ceilings and lots of natural light, a tastefully redone Kitchen with beautiful cabinetry and high-end appliances, impact windows and doors, and updated plumbing & electrical. Downstairs you will find an inviting family room off of the entry, a large dining and living room, butlers pantry and breakfast bar off of the well appointed kitchen, 2 spacious bedrooms and a spa like bath. Upstairs there is a spacious den/study, a huge master suite with a sitting area, luxurious bath, huge walk-in closet and private sun deck with river views. As you make your way out to the back of the home you will be impressed by the gorgeous resort style pool & spa, extremely large screened lanai, covered gazebo and guest house. Inside the spacious guest house is a kitchen area, full bath, bedroom/living area with a Murphy Bed and separate laundry room. This property is truly a tropical oasis with numerous varieties of lush native landscaping. Ideally located just a short stroll to watch the sunset at Snell Park, a quick golf cart ride to Fort Myers Country Club, or a leisurely bike ride to the Downtown River District. Make your appointment to see showplace today!

1335 Barcelona Ave, Fort Myers

$750,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224039315 MLS Edison Park BLDG.
This unique and stunning 1920’s Spanish style pool home situated on an oversized corner lot is located off iconic McGregor Boulevard in the Edison Park Historic district. Convenient location with the Edison Ford Estate campus and Edison Park Creative and Expressive Art School within walking distance. This exceptional 2 story home has 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 baths with master suite on the 2nd floor. You’ll be greeted by an open and bright floor plan featuring great room with bamboo flooring and Spanish style wood burning fireplace to cozy up to on those cooler evenings. Then move into the formal dining room with French doors leading to the pool area. The kitchen is a culinary enthusiast’s dream featuring stainless KitchenAid appliances with gas stove connected to a 250 gallon propane tank, built in microwave, granite counters with decorative tile backsplash, warm wood cabinetry, and opens to the dining area and great room for easy entertaining. Tasteful appointments include rich hardwood flooring, restoration hardware in kitchen and light fixtures, updated bathrooms with marble flooring and all new fixtures, and impressive staircase to 2nd floor. The master suite on the 2nd floor has soaring vaulted ceiling creating a bright and spacious atmosphere, walk in closet, en suite bath, engineered hardwood flooring, and isolated AC system. This home is perfect for entertaining with private back yard with paver patio and privacy fence. Your back yard will be your private oasis with beautiful heated lap pool and extended pool deck – great for entertaining friends and family. The dedicated laundry room is equipped with front load washer & dryer, and extra 3 door fridge. Other key features include upgraded plumbing, electric & HVAC, irrigation system, Generac whole house generator for peace of mind during inclement weather, impact resistant windows, workshop/storage building, and public water and sewer for reliability and convenience. Inviting curb appeal with fresh sod and new lush tropical landscaping, stately mature palms, and brick paved walkway leading to the front porch. Quiet community in close proximity to local waterways and beaches, dining, shopping, and golf courses makes this property ideal for the Florida lifestyle. Also, easy access to public parks with bike and walking trails and picnic areas, and boat ramps providing access to many waterways including the Peace and Myakka Rivers, beautiful Charlotte Harbor, and the Gulf of Mexico. Plus, the vibrant Fort Myers River District is nearby. This beautiful and truly unique home offers privacy, serenity, and luxury living for that special buyer. So don’t miss your chance to make this charming home yours.

2408 Euclid Ave, Fort Myers

$3,250,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 224038263 MLS Riverside BLDG.
**Professional photos and 3D Tour coming soon** Discover the charm and elegance of 1205 Caloosa Dr., a meticulously upgraded estate located in the historic Riverside McGregor area, near the Edison and Ford Estates and vibrant Historic Downtown Fort Myers. This grand home blends the allure of its rich history with the convenience of modern renovations, creating an inviting atmosphere that's hard to resist. As you step inside, you're welcomed by an expansive layout featuring 5 bedrooms, a cozy den, and 5 full bathrooms. The home is a testament to high-quality craftsmanship, showcasing impact-resistant windows, elegant crown molding, and premium upgrades that extend throughout the home. For those who love to cook and entertain, the property boasts two fully equipped kitchens, one on each floor. Both kitchens are fitted with high-end appliances and thoughtful finishes like double ovens. The main kitchen opens onto a lush lanai, complete with ceiling fans and integrated speakers, overlooking the sparkling waters of a solar/electric-heated saltwater pool and the Caloosahatchee River. Luxury continues in the master suite, where comfort meets design. It includes a deep soaking tub, a walk-in shower with body sprays, and a heater over the bidet, providing a spa-like experience at home. Practical features such as a tankless water heater, four efficient air conditioning units, and an epoxied garage floor with additional storage and laundry-tub connections ensure every need is met with ease. Surround sound system both inside and outside ensure that music and entertainment flow as seamlessly as the home’s design. Whether hosting lavish parties or enjoying a quiet evening, the ambiance is always "just right". The outdoor living spaces are equally impressive, featuring a large deck and patio area complete with travertine and marble cladding surrounded by mature bamboo and tropical flora, offering a private oasis for relaxation or entertainment. The appeal is enhanced by a newly installed roof, sturdy concrete block construction, and wind-rated protection for peace of mind. Custom fountain, metal gates, stair and lanai railings crafted by renowned metal artist James DiGeorgio, add an artistic touch to the estate’s aesthetic. The property is gated, with a beautifully paved circular driveway that adds to its charm. This home is not just a place to live; it’s a piece of Fort Myers' history, updated with the finest touches for modern luxury living. Experience the unique blend of history, luxury, and comfort at 1205 Caloosa Dr. Schedule a private showing today and feel the inviting warmth and undeniable charm of this exquisite Fort Myers estate.

1205 Caloosa Dr, Fort Myers

$489,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224030560 MLS Evans Addition BLDG.
Step back in time to the charm and character of 1920s Florida with this quaint bungalow nestled just moments from downtown Ft. Myers. Built in 1922, this historic gem exudes timeless elegance and period features that capture the essence of a bygone era. As you approach this charming residence, you're greeted by a picturesque facade adorned with classic architectural details, including a welcoming front porch perfect for enjoying balmy evenings and greeting neighbors with a friendly wave. Upon entering, you'll be enveloped in the warmth of yesteryear, with hardwood floors, intricate moldings, and vintage fixtures that evoke a sense of nostalgia. The cozy living room beckons you to unwind by the fireplace, while the dining area invites gatherings of family and friends for memorable meals. The kitchen, though retaining its historic charm, boasts modern conveniences to cater to contemporary lifestyles, offering a seamless blend of old-world allure and present-day functionality. Tucked away down the hallway, the bedrooms offer serene retreats, each infused with its own unique character and period touches. Imagine waking up to the soft glow of sunlight filtering through vintage windows, casting a golden hue over the space. Outside, the enchanting backyard provides a private oasis amidst lush greenery, where you can savor moments of tranquility or host delightful alfresco gatherings under the shade of swaying palms, and enjoying your own pool with deck. Conveniently located just a short distance from downtown Ft. Myers, this bungalow offers the best of both worlds – a serene sanctuary steeped in history, yet mere moments from the vibrant energy of city life. Experience the allure of vintage Florida living in this enchanting 1922 bungalow.

2622 Michigan Ave, Fort Myers

$899,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 224026484 MLS Poinciana Park BLDG.
Welcome to a slice of history nestled in McGregor's most historic district, where a stunning Spanish-style home awaits to enchant you with its timeless and distinctive charm. This remarkable property spreads over 3100+ SqFt of meticulously designed living space, accommodating 4 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms. As you step through the front door, you're immediately greeted by the rich warmth of pecky cypress planked ceilings, an architectural detail that harks back to a bygone era. The living area features a Mexican tile wood-burning fireplace, a focal point that adds a touch of rustic charm and a cozy ambiance to the space. The home is a haven for those who love to entertain or simply relish in their private retreat, featuring an oversized pool area and a sprawling outdoor space that is a blank canvas for your leisure and entertainment dreams, complemented by an oversized shed that provides ample storage for all your needs. The versatility of this home extends to the upstairs, where you'll find a flexible space that can easily be transformed into a workout room, a home office, or an extra living area, depending on your lifestyle and preferences. This residence isn't just a place to live; it's a gateway to the rich cultural tapestry of the area. Positioned just a stone's throw away from the scenic Snell Park, the home offers breathtaking views of the Caloosahatchee River, adding to its allure. The historic Edison Home and the vibrant Downtown Fort Myers are within a short walk, offering a glimpse into the area's past and a taste of its lively present. For golf enthusiasts, the Fort Myers Country Club is a mere golf cart ride away, perfect for enjoying a day on the greens!!

1326 Cordova Ave, Fort Myers

$585,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 224002889 MLS Dean Park BLDG.
HISTORIC DEAN PARK HOME. 3BR/2BA UNDER ONE ROOF. LOT 140’ WIDE. Built in 1915, the original cottage portion of this fully updated home was just the second property in historic Dean Park. The wing with the great room and primary bedroom was added in 2005, expanding the home to 1840 sq ft plus a huge garage with alley access. The oversized lot is filled with mature trees and lush landscaping. There’s a paver stone patio area enclosed by a privacy fence create your own Shangri-La in the heart of the city. Like all of Dean Park, the home was affected by Hurricane Ian, but the professional remediation preserved the charm of the original woodwork and brickwork--including a wood-burning fireplace in the entry room--but added the comfort and convenience of updated bathrooms and kitchen. With wooden cabinets, granite countertops and new stainless appliances, the kitchen is centrally located between the formal dining room and the large family room, making the home perfect for entertaining, inside or out. The spacious primary bedroom suite is large and has two walk-in closets. The primary bath has a walk-in shower. A wrap-around front porch and two side porches invite you to relax and enjoy the tranquil environment. Huge attached garage has a bright workshop, perfect for people who tinker or garden. Or it could be converted into additional living space. There’s extra space outside to park vehicles or machinery but it is separated from the entertainment patio by the privacy fence. Although the home has city water, there is a well that feeds a buried sprinkler system. Day or night, you can stroll the tree lined sidewalks along quiet pet friendly streets to absorb the historic environment of Dean Park. Add a few steps to reach the downtown River District with its plethora of restaurant and entertainment choices, plus the river front park with its newly added play area and band shell. Seller offering a $7000 flooring allowance

2728 Providence St, Fort Myers

Start Your Search